Clinical trials have established that cardiac resynchronization therapy crt, either alone or in combination with an implantable cardioverterdefibrillator icd crtd, improves survival and heart failure hf symptoms in appropriately selected patients. Feb 20, 2009 sensitivity 10% when compared with sgarbossas study specificity 88% with a sensitivity of 53%. The presence of a complete lbbb makes the diagnosis of myocardial infarction by ecg difficult. Prevalence of manual strauss lbbb criteria in patients. Concordant st elevation 1mm in leads with a positive qrs complex score 5 concordant st depression 1 mm in v1v3 score 3 excessively discordant st elevation 5 mm in leads with a ve qrs complex score 2. Introduction left bundle branch block lbbb is a common conduction abnormality. Here is a similar graphic i created this morning by cropping actual ecgs. Criteria smith 2012 criteria 1 and 2 are preserved in their current state. Sgarbossa e, pinski s, et al for the gusto1 investigators. A new lbbb is always pathological and can be a sign of myocardial infarction. Jan 05, 2017 we know the prevalence of lbbb in the general population has been reported to range from 0.
A 76yearold woman presents to the ed with chest pain that radiates to the neck, jaw and teeth. St segment is in the opposite direction to the majority of the qrs rule of appropriate discordance. In the framingham study, coincident with or subsequent to the detection of lbbb, 48% of individuals developed symptomatic cad or chf. Editor,we read with interest the paper about the electrocardiographic diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction ami in patients with left bundle branch block lbbb. Diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction in left bundle branch block. Kowey and li zhang lankenau medical center, lankenau institute for medical research usa 1. Subsequent ekg showed lbbb and met sgarbossa criteria figure 1b. The diagnostic criteria to identify acute myocardial infarction in the presence of left bundle branch block sgarbossa s criteria was originally based on a rise and fall of cardiac biomarkers, not angiography in other words it combined stemi and nstemi. Specificity of the modified criteria was not statistically different from the original weighted criteria 99% vs 100%, p.
Enhancing the sgarbossa criteria for the diagnosis of st. In a lbbb, the last depolarization wave is in the left ventricle. Sgarbossa criteria can be used to help diagnose ami in setting of lbbb. The normal sequence of activation is altered dramatically in lbbb, with a resultant characteristic appearance on the ecg waveform 1. Identifying stemi in the presence of lbbb sgarbossas. Following criteria exactly, even the modified sgarbossa. Bundlebranch block morphology and other predictors of. In a previous article i showed this graphic which was created using powerpoint. A large clinical trial of thrombolytic therapy for. The modified sgarbossa criteria were proposed in a derivation study to be superior to the original criteria for diagnosing acute coronary occlusion aco in left bundle branch block lbbb. Combining sgarbossa and selvester ecg criteria to improve stemi detection in the presence of lbbb.
They also state that if there is more than 1mm deflection in the same direction as the major qrs in any one lead you can call it an acute mi. Apr 27, 2015 making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 2. Lbbb, however sgarbossa et al in 1996 described some ecg changes. Widely recognised conventional criteria for lbbb, also applied in large trials. The sgarbossa criteria the three classical sgarbossa ecg criteria for myocardial infarction in the presence of a lbbb.
Qiangjun cai, md,a,b,e nilay mehta, do,a,e elena b. Elena sgarbossa is a pretty cool cardiologist she asked if there were clues that could be found to identify ami in the face of a lbbb she used data from the famous gusto1. Background the modified sgarbossa criteria were proposed in a derivation study to be superior to the original criteria for diagnosing acute coronary occlusion aco in left bundle branch block lbbb. Sgarbossa criteria and left bundle branch block youtube. Apr 18, 2017 criteria used for acute awmi with prior lbbb is sgarbossa criteria 1. Discordance should be proportional to the qrs, with an sts or str ratio no greater than 0.
Modified sgarbossa criteria 10 april,2015 antoine ayer left bundle branch block lbbb preclude the detection of stemi because the st segment is usually deviated in all leads in the presence of lbbb. Since lbbb changes the sequence of ventricular depolarization the usual voltage criteria for lvh diagnosis do not pertain. Criteria to diagnose acute mi in patients with prior lbbb. Sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction cmaj. Sgarbossas is a well accepted approach at determining which lbbb are having an mi. Are the sgarbossa criteria ready for prime time am heart j 20 sep. From falsely declaring emergency to denying reperfusion in a highrisk population.
Acute myocardial infarction in patients with left bundle. Pdf validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria for. Evolving considerations in the management of patients with left bundle branch block and suspected myocardial infarction. Learn how to determine whether a patient with a lbbb or pacermaker is having an acute myocardial infarction. St elevation myocardial infarction in lbbb core em. Left bundle branch block lbbb during anaesthesia is uncommon. Sgarbossa criteria academic emergency medicine education. The last activity on the ecg thus goes to the left or away from v1. Sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction article pdf available in canadian medical association journal 18815 april 2016 with 612 reads how we measure reads. Its often difficult to identify an mi for patients with existing left bundle branch blocks lbbb. During general anaesthesia, lbbb may be related to hypertension or tachycardia and its acute onset makes the diagnosis of acute myocardial ischemia or infarction difficult. They derived 3 criteria which may help diagnose the hidden ami. Left bundle branch block lbbb is a major ecg confounder for st.
Left bundle branch block without concordant st changes is. To diagnose stemi in lbbb we have the much famed sgarbosa criteria. Sep 16, 20 the sgarbossa criteria is described in the cardiology literature by neeland et al who conclude in their paper. Sgarbossa criteria in bundle branch blocks and paced. Am i correct that since the common frequency for the p wave 0. The criteria of stsegment depression in v1, v2 or v3 had similar test characteristics to sgarbossas study sensitivity of 19%, specificity of 81% compared with a sensitivity of 29% and specificity of 82% in sgarbossas study. The left bundlebranch block puzzle in the 20 stelevation myocardial infarction guideline. Left bundle branch block lbbb, a pattern seen on the surface electrocardiogram ecg, results when normal electrical activity in the hispurkinje system is interrupted. In addition, the sequence of ventricular repolarization is also changed. It is a too popular to forget in spite of its limited utility. Apr 14, 2011 the sgarbossa criteria say that if there is more than 5mm elevation in the opposite direction of the major qrs deflection in any one lead you can call this an acute mi middle tracing above.
Once you remember this, lbbb is easy to understand. Pdf sgarbossa criteria are highly specific for acute myocardial. The electrocardiographic criteria for the diagnosis of infarction were then tested in an independent sample of patients presenting with acute chest pain and left bundlebranch block. Sgarbossa criteria are highly specific for acute myocardial. Historically, reperfusion decisions in lbbb have been determined by the original sgarbossa criteria published in 1996, but there are three key limitations to the original study by sgarbossa et al. Validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria filed under. Sgarbossa criteria for diagnosis of acute stemi in the setting of left bundle branch block lbbb researchers have strived to identify ecg criteria for diagnosis of acute stemi in the setting of lbbb. Clinical prediction, cardiac enzymes are safe and could be more accurate. The left bundle branch arises from the bundle of his, and subsequently is divided into the anterior and posterior fascicles. Which patients with suspected myocardial ischemia and left. The ecg patterns and cardiac function in patients with and without coronary artery disease marwan badri, william kornberg, james f. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 3.
Sgarbossa criteria in left bundle branch block in a. Pdf sgarbossa criteria for acute myocardial infarction. Sgarbossas criteria for mi in left bundle branch block. Sgarbossa s criteria are a set of electrocardiographic findings generally used to identify myocardial infarction also called acute myocardial infarction or a heart attack in the presence of a left bundle branch block lbbb or a ventricular paced rhythm. In 1996 sgarbossa et al 3 identified three ekg criteria that may improve the diagnosis of stemi in patients with left bundle branch block 1. The new rule replaces the third criterion 5 mm of excessively discordant st elevation ste with a proportion at least 1 mm ste and stes wave 0. St elevation in atleast one lead of 1mm concordant to positive qrs complex5 2. Cardiology, lbbb, sgarbossa criteria, stemi september 29th, 2016 leave a comment it has been recognized since the 1940s that the presence of a left bundle branch block lbbb obscures the ekg diagnosis of myocardial infarction mi. Sgarbossa s criteria can be used in cases of patients with a preexisting lbbb a. Patients with a suspected acs in the setting of lbbb represent a much more heterogeneous population than stemi without bbb and present unique diagnostic and therapeutic challenges to the clinician.
Advised aortic dissection detection risk score plus ddimer for aortic syndromes rule out aortic dissection and other aortic syndromes smithmodified sgarbossa s criteria for mi in left bundle branch block diagnose acute mi in patients with known lbbb sgarbossa s criteria for mi in left bundle branch block allows for the diagnosis of. Nov 01, 2016 backgroundas the incidence of left bundle branch blocks lbbbs and pacedrhythms electrocardiograms ecgs increase in the aging global population, the need for rapid and accurate diagnosis of stelevation myocardial infarction stemi or stemi equivalents in patients with these rhythms becomes more imperative. Assessment for lvh is clearly more difficult in the presence of lbbb. Oct 18, 2016 the sgarbossa criteria consist of stsegment elevation of 1 mm or more concordant with the qrs complex i.
Sgarbossa s criteria in 1996, sgarbossa et al looked through the gusto1 trial patients with lbbb and ami. An introduction to understanding sgarbossa criteria and left bundle branch blocks. The criteria can be used in patients with bundle branch block bbb and paced rhythm. The prevalence of the lbbb criteria defined by strauss et al. Left bundle branch block lbbb results in an altered pattern of left ventricular lv activation and.
We determined a the presence or absence of sgarbossa criteria with concordant scon or discordant sdis st changes, b the presence of acute coronary occlusion or likely recent occlusion on angiography and c the biochemical evidence of myocardial infarction troponin t 0. Sgarbossadown and dirty american heart association. In part 1 of this series we discussed why left bundle branch block presents a dilemma for clinicians who provide care for patients who suffer chest pain or other signs and symptoms of acs. Sgarbossa criteria in bundle branch blocks and paced rhythm. In this rule, the replacement of the third sgarbossa component excessively discordant stsegment elevation as defined by 5 mm of stsegment elevation in the setting of a negative qrs with one defined proportionally by stsegment elevation to swave depth sts ratio was. The sgarbossa and smithmodified sgarbossa criteria have been documented to. M ethods derivation sample criteria for the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction in the presence of left bundlebranch block were developed from two populations the study and control groups, which constituted the derivation sample. Structured literature search in medline, lilacs, ovid, and embase from january 1996.
Pdf ecg detection of stsegment elevation myocardial infarction stem. The sgarbossa criteria is used in the diagnosis of an acute myocardial infarction when a left bundle branch block is present. Left bundle branch block lbbb normally the septum is activated from left to right, producing small q waves in the lateral leads. Making sense of sgarbossa s criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 2. Diagnosis of stelevation myocardial infarction in the. A modified sgarbossa rule 4 has been suggested for the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction in the presence of lbbb. Validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria for acute coronary occlusion in the setting of left bundle branch block. Validation of the modified sgarbossa criteria for acute. Acute myocardial infarction and left branch bundle block. Given that lbbb is associated with a high mortality, any patient with chest pain and lbbb should be discussed with a senior emergency doctor andor cardiologist at an early stage. Another example of left bundle branch block on a 12 lead ecg. Combining sgarbossa and selvester ecg criteria to improve stemi.
Electrocardiographic diagnosis of myocardial infarction in the presence of bundle branch block or a paced rhythm view in chinese seen, particularly if the stt vectors are in the same direction as the qrs complex as in the sgarbossa criteria described below. Apr 17, 2019 meyers hp, limkakeng at jr, jaffa ej, et al. Sgarbossa s is a well accepted approach at determining which lbbb are having an mi. The original three criteria used to diagnose infarction in patients with lbbb are. The reason for not meeting strauss criteria was mainly due to short qrs duration criteria for the ecg diagnosis of stemi in the setting of lbbb have been developed and may help identify patients presenting with chest pain and lbbb who are more likely to be experiencing an mi. Pdf combining sgarbossa and selvester ecg criteria to improve. In 1996, sgarbossa et al26 published an analysis from the gusto1 trial evaluating different ecg criteria to diagnose ami in the presence of lbbb. Combining sgarbossa and selvester ecg criteria to improve stemi detection. The anterior fascicle is usually supplied by septal perforators from the left anterior descending artery, and the posterior fascicle typically has a dual supply from septal. In other words, the modified sgarbossa criteria only changes the last of the original sgarbossa criteria with the first two criteria staying intact. Elena sgarbossa is a pretty cool cardiologist she asked if there were clues that could be found to identify ami in the face of a lbbb she used data from the famous gusto1 trial.
Stateoftheart criteria article pdf available in international cardiovascular research journal 72. Diagnostic criteria the qrs width should be greater than or equal to 120 ms in adults, 100 ms in children of 416 years. Response to shortcomings of the original sgarbossa criteria attempting to increase the value of criteria 3 and, subsequently, increase the sensitivity for detection of ami in the setting of a lbbb. Sgarbossa et al proposed requiring at least 3 points from the following criteria for the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction in the presence of left bundle branch block. The baseline st segments and t waves tend to be shifted in a discordant direction appropriate discordance, which can mask or mimic acute myocardial infarction. St segment is in the same direction as the majority of the qrs discordance. In lbbb, the normal direction of septal depolarisation is reversed becomes right to left, as the impulse spreads first to the rv via the right bundle branch and then to the lv via the septum. The most commonly used criteria to help differentiate an acute mi is the sgarbossa criteria from the gusto1 trial. Dec, 2008 cardiac rhythm analysis, 12lead ecg interpretation, resuscitation. Meeting the criteria in a single lead can be specific for ami. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle. Conflicts of interest comprise financial interests, activities, and relationships within the past 3 years including but not limited to employment, affiliation, grants or funding, consultancies, honoraria or payment, speakers bureaus, stock ownership or options, expert testimony, royalties, donation of medical. Sgarbossas crit eria are a set of electrocardiographic findings generally used to identify myocardial infarction also called acute myocardial infarction or a heart attack in the presence of a left bundle branch block lbbb or a ventricular paced rhythm myocardial infarction mi is often difficult to detect when lbbb is present on ecg.
The sgarbossa ecg criteria are the most validated tool. Discordant st elevation 5mm in atleast one leads with prominant negative qrs2 a total of 3 points suggests. Smithmodified sgarbossa criteria and paced rhythms. St elevation 1mm in leads with a positive qrs complex concordance in st deviation score 5. Presentation by mark liao, uc davis school of medicine, class. Sgarbossa concordant criteria and an lbbb known to be old. The criteria sgarbossa 1 that can be used in case of a lbbb and suspicion of infarction are. Sgarbossa criteria in left bundle branch block in a hypertensive.
In the original sgarbossa criteria, a score of apr 23, 2015 making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 1. Combining sgarbossa and selvester ecg criteria to improve. Left bundle branch block under general anaesthesia in an. Here is a graphic i created to help explain sgarbossas criteria for identifying acute myocardial infarction ami in the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb or paced rhythm. The sgarbossa criteria consist of stsegment elevation of 1 mm or more concordant with the qrs complex i. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria chest pain and left. We would like to present a case report of a healthy patient who developed lbbb intra operatively. Myocardial infarction mi is often difficult to detect when lbbb is present on ecg. Sgarbossa criteria background in patients with left bundle branch block lbbb or ventricular paced rhythm, infarct diagnosis based on the ecg is difficult. Rather, the 2 were merged into a single category, as. The left bundlebranch block puzzle in the 20 stelevation. Diagnosis of myocardial infarction in lbbb can be difficult. St segments in all leads should be discordant to the majority of the qrs. In a lbbb, the left ventricle is depolarized later than the right ventricle.
Sgarbossa identified 3 criteria used in a 10point scale that improved the specificity of the diagnosis of stemi in patients with lbbb. Myocardial infarction diagnosis in the presence of left bundle branch block lbbb or ventricular paced rhythm. Consequently, a lbbb makes it difficult to diagnose an acute mi. Criteria for the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction in the presence of left bundlebranch block were developed from two populations the study and control groups, which. The pain is associated with nausea, dyspnea, and diaphoresis. Making sense of sgarbossas criteria ecg medical training. The above definition of left bundle branch block is rather broad. Tabas ja, rodriguez rm, seligman hk, goldschlager nf. Left bundle branch block presents a dilemma for many clinicians in the evaluation of chest pain or other signs and symptoms of acs and its easy to see why. The presence of deep t wave inversions in leads with a predominantly negative. The modified sgarbossa criteria were superior to the original criteria for identifying aco in lbbb. Infarction stemi in the presence of left bundlebranch block lbbb has long been a challenge. Identify all potential conflicts of interest that might be relevant to your comment. Making sense of sgarbossa s criteria chest pain and left bundle branch block part 1.
634 505 788 1151 994 35 116 1418 1294 574 207 1084 479 638 360 1495 1013 132 482 1189 539 661 1287 1392 411 110 1204 790 690 1429 456 977 123 556 360 979 1310 841 897 1132 1276 392